Skip to Content

Homemade Flour Tortillas

I make all of my own baked goods, tortillas included. I don’t necessarily do it because I think it’s more frugal (though it is); rather, I’m a control freak and I like to know what’s in my food (at least 75% of the time, anyway). Plus, I think they taste better!

My mom gave me a tortilla maker for Christmas a few years ago and I use the recipe that came with it. I’ve been asked repeatedly for this recipe but have never gotten around to sharing it, for whatever reason. Finally – I’m blogging directions for making tortillas!

Ingredients:

3 cups whole wheat flour – I use freshly ground hard white wheat (the directions call for half WW, half unbleached)
1 tsp salt
1/3 cup oil (I use coconut oil or butter)
1 cup warm water
Place flour and salt in a mixer bowl. Add oil and process for about 3 seconds. With machine running, pour water in a steady stream. Let machine run until dough forms a ball. Dough should be a medium-stiff consistency. If dough is too stiff, add a little more water.

Divide dough into 12-15 equal pieces.

Cover with plastic wrap and let rest at least 30 minutes.

Press with a tortilla maker.

I don’t have one of these fancy-schmancy tortilla warmers so I just keep my tortillas warm by wrapping them in a clean kitchen towel. One of these days, though, I might get a tortilla warmer and jazz it up a bit!

To save time, I usually double or triple the recipe. If I think we’ll be eating tortillas a few times in one week, I just put the extra dough in the fridge and make tortillas as needed. They’re so much better hot off the press! Otherwise, I’ll bag up the extra dough and freeze it. Then, when I want to make fresh tortillas, I just pull a bag out of the freezer, let it thaw in the fridge, and then press tortillas. It works great.

A note about Tortilla Makers – you can see tortilla maker I use here – Cucina Flatbread & Tortilla Maker. It costs $72 because it presses AND cooks them, and it works ok. Sometimes, I prefer to just use it to press the tortillas instead of also cooking them. I’ve recently found out that I get a slightly better result by finishing them off on my Lodge cast iron griddle – and it goes quicker too. I’ve been looking at this much cheaper tortilla press here Cast Iron Tortilla Press– all it does is press them. It doesn’t also cook them like mine does. If I had to do it all over again, I’d probably go with the cheaper $20 version.

And there you have it. Homemade. Flour. Tortillas. Not that hard and incredibly yummy. Occasionally, I also make corn tortillas. But I don’t like them as much so I don’t make them as often. Let me know if you’re curious about them as well and one of these days, I’ll share that recipe, too!

Linking up: Frugal Tuesday; Hearth & Soul Hop; Homemade Tuesday; Fat Tuesday; Tutorial Tuesday; Anti-Procrastination Tuesday; Frugal Days, Sustainable Ways; Works for Me Wednesday; Simple Lives Thursday; Creative Juice; Full Plate Thursday

Sheri

Friday 8th of June 2012

I have the press you mention and I hate it. It's easier to roll out than to use the press. Or maybe I am doing it wrong. I read somewhere they are for corn tortillas not flour.

Michelle

Friday 8th of June 2012

Interesting, thank you!

Miz Helen

Sunday 11th of March 2012

Hi Michelle, We love homemade Tortillas, I wish I had your Tortilla Press, that would be so nice. I will have to try you whole wheat recipe, it looks great! Hope you are having a great week end and thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday. Happy St. Patrick's Day and Come Back Soon! Miz Helen

Foy Update: Garden. Cook. Write. Repeat.

Thursday 8th of March 2012

I've taken enchiladas off our menu because I didn't like buying the store bought kind. I have finally mastered bread, so perhaps tortillas are next; that or pasta.

I think I would go for a cast iron press over aluminum. Even though you aren't cooking in the aluminum I'd just feel more comfortable.

Michelle

Friday 9th of March 2012

Yeah. I hear you. I figured though, since nothing is being heated, the aluminum is probably just fine.

Elsa

Thursday 8th of March 2012

I love to make my own tortillas too. And the taste is so much better.

kristy lynn @ Gastronomical Sovereignty

Wednesday 7th of March 2012

high five for control freaks! and high five for knowing what's in your food. i do that not only because i'm a control freak but also because what goes into store bought baked goods is s-c-a-r-y.

SimplifyLiveLove is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.