Alternatives to Turkey for Thanksgiving: 15 Dinner Ideas + 4 Easy Menus

No Comments

Add As A Trusted Google Source

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

Do you love the side dishes of Thanksgiving but feel indifferent about the turkey? It’s tradition, but there’s no rule that says you have to roast a bird you don’t enjoy. If you’re looking for alternatives to turkey for Thanksgiving this year, you’re not alone, and you have plenty of tasty options.

Here are four themed Thanksgiving menus my family loves, plus 15 main dishes to choose from if turkey didn’t earn a place on your menu this year.

thanksgiving place setting with wine glass and pumpkin

Quick Guide to Thanksgiving Dinner Without Turkey

Skipping the turkey makes Thanksgiving easier, cheaper, or just more fun. Here’s what you’ll find below:

  • Four themed menus: Indian, Chinese, Italian, and a taco bar, each built around dishes your family already likes.
  • 15 main dish alternatives: rack of lamb, beef tenderloin, prime rib, bourbon glazed ham, roast duck, beef Wellington, mushroom Wellington, seafood pasta, and more.
  • Vegetarian mains that hold their own in the center of the table.
  • Easy meat swaps like pot roast, pork tenderloin, ham, and roast chicken that still go with all the classic sides.
  • Make-ahead and small-group picks so you can free up the oven and the day.

Planning the whole meal? Grab my free printable Thanksgiving planner and these make-ahead Thanksgiving sides.

Why Skip the Turkey on Thanksgiving?

The traditional Thanksgiving meal of turkey, mashed potatoes, and all the trimmings isn’t for everyone. Some families just don’t love turkey. Some hosts are cooking for a small group and don’t want a 15-pound bird. And some years turkeys are pricey or hard to find.

Whatever your reason, a turkey-free Thanksgiving can be just as festive. Pick a culturally inspired menu, go fancy with prime rib or lamb, or keep it simple with a main dish everyone already asks for.

Indian Thanksgiving dinner spread with tandoori chicken, naan, rice pilaf, and palak paneer

Indian Thanksgiving Dinner Menu

My family loves Indian food. It’s easy to take the traditional Thanksgiving menu and give it an Indian twist: simply adding Indian spices to familiar dishes makes a delicious Thanksgiving feast. Indian cooking also includes lots of vegetarian dishes, which makes it easier to feed guests with different diets.

An Indian Thanksgiving menu might include:

  • Whole tandoori chicken
  • Spiced roasted butternut squash
  • Cranberry chutney
  • Palak paneer
  • Vegan shami kebabs
  • Green beans poriyal
  • Naan
  • Rice pilaf

Why it works: Tandoori chicken takes the place of the turkey, and cranberry chutney and butternut squash keep the fall flavors everyone expects.

Homemade Chinese food with egg rolls and fried rice as an alternative to turkey for Thanksgiving

Chinese Feast for Thanksgiving

Who doesn’t love Chinese food? Our favorite Chinese dishes are simple to make at home, which makes this the perfect alternative to turkey when you don’t want to spend all day in the kitchen. My family would happily trade turkey for a homemade Chinese takeout night.

A Chinese Thanksgiving menu might include:

Why it works: Egg rolls can be rolled and frozen ahead, so the day of, you’re mostly stir-frying. I’m hungry just thinking about it.

Italian buffet with pasta, garlic bread, and salad for a turkey-free Thanksgiving

Italian Buffet: An Easy Alternative to Turkey for Thanksgiving

If you’re wondering what to make besides turkey, try an Italian buffet or a homestyle Italian dinner. Use homemade tomato sauce and dried herbs from your garden for the best flavor, and stick to your family’s favorites.

My Italian Thanksgiving menu looks like this:

Why it works: Lasagna and meatballs both freeze well, so you can make them days ahead and just bake on Thanksgiving.

Pin this now to find it later

Pin It
Mexican taco bar spread with taco meat, guacamole, and cowboy caviar for Thanksgiving dinner

Tacos Instead of Turkey: Mexican-Inspired Thanksgiving Ideas

We eat tacos all the time at our house because it’s one meal everyone loves. For a holiday, I make my standard taco bar a little fancier and add a few extra sides like cornbread or corn casserole. Serve Mexican desserts, or stick with the traditional pumpkin and pecan pies.

A Mexican-inspired Thanksgiving menu might include:

Why it works: A taco bar lets everyone build their own plate, which makes picky eaters and special diets easy to handle.

Vegetarian Thanksgiving Main Dishes

If you’re feeding vegetarians, or just want the vegetables to be the star, there are plenty of meatless mains that feel special enough for the holiday:

  • Mushroom Wellington: All the drama of beef Wellington with a savory mushroom filling. Find a make-ahead version in the list below.
  • Stuffed pumpkin or winter squash: The cornbread, mushroom, and kale stuffed pumpkin in the list below makes a stunning centerpiece.
  • Indian menu, minus the chicken: Palak paneer, vegan shami kebabs, and green beans poriyal make a full vegetarian meal.
  • Veggie lasagna: Load it with spinach, mushrooms, and zucchini.
  • Raclette dinner: Melted cheese over potatoes and vegetables, cooked right at the table.
Get new posts sent to your inbox!
Don’t miss out! Subscribe and get all the new posts first.

15 Delicious Alternatives to Turkey for Thanksgiving

Here are 15 main dish alternatives to turkey your family will ask for year after year!

Lamb-Rack-Main

Rosemary Garlic Rack of Lamb

A roast rack of lamb is my idea of a fancy holiday meal. I've never cooked one myself, but these directions make it look easy.
Get the Recipe
New-York-Strips-in-cast-iron-skillet

New York Strip Steak with Rosemary Garlic

If your family is a steak and potatoes crowd, they'll love this easy New York strip steak cooked in a cast iron skillet.
Get the Recipe
Marinated beef tenderloin

Marinated Beef Tenderloin

Helpful tips for a tender, flavorful beef tenderloin, with an easy homemade marinade and a horseradish dipping sauce.
Get the Recipe
stuffed duck

Maple Glazed Roast Duck

I've never roasted a duck, but I've eaten it in Paris and it's always a hit. If you've been thinking about duck, start here.
Get the Recipe
egg rolls on a plate

Homemade Egg Rolls

We love homemade egg rolls. They take some time to roll, but they're worth the effort, and they freeze well so you can make them ahead.
Get the Recipe
stuffed pumpkin

Cornbread, Mushroom, and Kale Stuffed Pumpkin

A beautiful vegetarian main dish that looks right at home in the center of the Thanksgiving table.
Get the Recipe
Vegan Mushroom Wellington

Vegan Mushroom Wellington

Juicy mushrooms take center stage in this vegan mushroom wellington – a fun spin on the classic beef wellington.
Get the Recipe
creamy lobster pappardelle

Creamy Lobster Pasta

A rich, creamy lobster pappardelle I'd love to be served on Thanksgiving.
Get the Recipe
raclette cheeses and wine glasses

Raclette Dinner

A fun, interactive meal for cheese lovers. Guests cook their own dinner at the table, so there's very little cooking for you.
Get the Recipe
Individual-Beef-Wellington

Individual Beef Wellington

Seared filet mignon wrapped in herbed mushrooms, prosciutto, and flaky puff pastry, with make-ahead and freezing instructions.
Get the Recipe
bourbon-ham

Bourbon Glazed Ham

My kids revolt if turkey is the only protein on the menu. They'd much rather have ham, and this bourbon glaze sounds amazing.
Get the Recipe
Creamy-seafood-pasta

Creamy Garlic Seafood Pasta

I've had creamy garlic seafood pasta at restaurants lately and always want more. Why not serve a fancy pasta instead of turkey?
Get the Recipe
three salmon tacos

Salmon Street Tacos

My family requests these salmon tacos often. Serve them with taco meat, guacamole, crema, beans, and rice for a Thanksgiving taco bar.
Get the Recipe
prime rib

Holiday Prime Rib

Learn how to make prime rib for a special Thanksgiving dinner your family will remember.
Get the Recipe
sliced pork roast

Balsamic Rosemary Instant Pot Pork Roast

This pork roast cooks in the Instant Pot in a fraction of the time a turkey takes, and it frees up your oven for sides.
Get the Recipe

Other Main Dishes Besides Turkey

If you love the standard Thanksgiving sides and just want a different main dish, try one of these. Each one goes with mashed potatoes, stuffing, and green beans just as well as turkey does.

  • Glazed ham: My kids revolt if turkey is the only protein on the menu, and ham is their pick. It feeds a crowd, and a precooked ham mostly needs warming and glazing.
  • Pot roast: Make it in the Instant Pot and keep your oven free for sides and pies.
  • Pork roast or pork loin: Feeds a family for less money than beef, and you can marinate it the day before.
  • Pork tenderloin: Cooks fast, so it’s a good pick for a small Thanksgiving for two or four.
  • Roast chicken: All the roast bird feel of Thanksgiving at a fraction of the size and time.
  • Duck breasts: A fancy option for a small group.
  • Individual pot pies: Make them ahead and bake them on the day. Swap the turkey for chicken if you’re skipping turkey entirely.

And if one turkey lover won’t budge, make a small bird with my no-fail upside down turkey method and serve it alongside one of these.

Mix and Match Thanksgiving Side Dishes

Once I let go of holiday expectations, I found I love making Thanksgiving dishes with a twist. I start with the traditional menu:

Then I give it a different spin. Some years it’s small tweaks to the classics. Other years I take inspiration from another cuisine and build a whole new menu, like the Indian Thanksgiving menu above.

If sweet potato casserole and green beans aren’t your thing, mix and match other sides. You can even group several vegetarian sides together for a complete meal. A few favorites:

Thanksgiving Without Turkey FAQ

What can I serve instead of turkey for Thanksgiving?

Popular alternatives to turkey for Thanksgiving include glazed ham, prime rib, beef tenderloin, pork roast, roast chicken, rack of lamb, and roast duck. You can also skip the roast entirely and serve a themed menu, like Indian, Chinese, Italian, or a taco bar.

What is the best Thanksgiving main dish for a small group?

Pork tenderloin, duck breasts, a roast chicken, or individual beef Wellingtons all work well for two to four people. They cook faster than a turkey and leave fewer leftovers.

What Thanksgiving main can I make ahead?

Lasagna, pot pies, meatballs, and taco meat can all be made days ahead and frozen. Pot roast in the Instant Pot is another good choice because it frees up your oven on the day.

What do vegetarians eat for Thanksgiving dinner?

Mushroom Wellington, stuffed pumpkin or squash, veggie lasagna, an Indian spread with palak paneer and vegan kebabs, or a raclette dinner all make a satisfying vegetarian Thanksgiving main.

How much meat should I plan per person?

A common rule of thumb is about 1/2 pound of boneless meat or 3/4 to 1 pound of bone-in meat per person. Plan a little more if you want leftovers.

Is it okay not to have turkey on Thanksgiving?

Absolutely. Thanksgiving is about gathering and gratitude. Serve the meal your family will enjoy most, whether that’s ham, tacos, or lasagna.

Plan Your Turkey-Free Thanksgiving

Whatever you choose to eat for Thanksgiving this year, grab my printable Thanksgiving planner to help you plan and pull off an amazing holiday meal.

More Thanksgiving Ideas to Try

About Michelle Marine

Michelle Marine is an Iowa hobby farmer, from-scratch cook, SATW travel writer, and the author of How to Raise Chickens for Meat. She's lived on three continents, driven four kids across the entire USA solo, and traded her Iowa kitchen for press trips in Colombia and beyond. She writes about real food, hobby farm life, and firsthand travel at SimplifyLiveLove.com: a life worth savoring, no perfection required.

You May Also Like:

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *